Critically discuss Sartre's conception of choice and responsibility in the light of the above statement.

← all philosophy optional previous year questions

The following answer addresses the question "Critically discuss Sartre's conception of choice and responsibility in the light of the above statement.".

Jean-Paul Sartre's philosophy, particularly his existentialist views, has significantly influenced modern thought, especially in the realms of ethics, responsibility, and choice. Sartre's conception of choice and responsibility is deeply rooted in his belief in human freedom and the absence of any inherent meaning in life. This essay will critically discuss Sartre's views on choice and responsibility, examining their implications and limitations.

The Absurdity of Existence

Sartre begins his exploration of human existence with the notion of the absurd. In his seminal work "L'Être et le Néant" (Being and Nothingness), Sartre argues that human beings are "condemned to be free" (Sartre, 1943). This freedom is not a positive attribute but a burden, as it implies that humans are responsible for their own existence and must create their own meaning in a world that is fundamentally indifferent to their existence.

Choice and Freedom

Sartre's concept of choice is closely tied to his notion of freedom. He posits that humans are free to choose their actions and that these choices are not determined by any external factors, such as God, fate, or societal structures. This freedom is not a passive state but an active engagement with the world. In "L'Être et le Néant," Sartre writes, "Man is condemned to be free; because once thrown into the world, he is responsible for everything he does" (Sartre, 1943).

Sartre's view of freedom is not a mere theoretical construct but a practical reality. He argues that humans are constantly making choices, whether they are aware of it or not. These choices are not merely about trivial matters but about the very essence of one's being. For instance, choosing to live a life of integrity or choosing to succumb to societal pressures are both choices that define a person's character and values.

Responsibility and Authenticity

Responsibility, for Sartre, is an inevitable consequence of freedom. Since humans are free to choose their actions, they are also responsible for the consequences of those actions. This responsibility is not something that can be avoided or delegated. In "L'Être et le Néant," Sartre writes, "The responsibility of man is to choose his own being" (Sartre, 1943). This choice, however, is not a one-time event but a continuous process of self-creation.

Sartre's notion of authenticity is closely linked to his views on responsibility. Authenticity, for Sartre, is the state of being true to oneself, of living in accordance with one's own values and choices. It is the opposite of bad faith, which is the state of denying one's freedom and responsibility. In "L'Être et le Néant," Sartre argues that humans can choose to live inauthentically, to conform to societal expectations or to avoid responsibility. However, this is a choice, and thus, it is still a form of responsibility.

The Role of Others

Sartre's views on choice and responsibility are not isolated from the social context. He acknowledges the influence of others on our choices and actions. In his essay "Existentialism is a Humanism," Sartre discusses the "look" of others, which can either liberate or oppress individuals. The "look" of others can either affirm or deny our freedom, and it is this interaction with others that shapes our choices and responsibilities.

Sartre's views on the role of others are not without criticism. Some argue that his emphasis on individual freedom and responsibility overlooks the structural and systemic factors that can limit individual agency. For instance, Marxist critics argue that Sartre's focus on individual choice ignores the role of economic and social structures in shaping human behavior (Marcuse, 1964).

The Problem of Bad Faith

One of the central themes in Sartre's philosophy is the concept of bad faith. Bad faith is the state of denying one's freedom and responsibility. It is a form of self-deception where individuals pretend that their actions are determined by external factors rather than their own choices. In "L'Être et le Néant," Sartre writes, "Bad faith is a lie to oneself, a lie which is not a lie to others" (Sartre, 1943).

Sartre argues that bad faith is a common human response to the burden of freedom. It is a way of avoiding the responsibility that comes with freedom. However, he also argues that bad faith is a form of self-betrayal, a denial of one's true nature. The only way to overcome bad faith, according to Sartre, is to acknowledge and embrace one's freedom and responsibility.

Critique of Sartre's Views

While Sartre's views on choice and responsibility have been influential, they are not without criticism. One of the primary criticisms is that his emphasis on individual freedom and responsibility overlooks the role of societal structures and external factors in shaping human behavior. Critics argue that Sartre's view of humans as completely free and responsible ignores the reality of social, economic, and political constraints (Marcuse, 1964).

Another criticism is that Sartre's view of freedom is too abstract and does not account for the practical difficulties of making choices. Critics argue that Sartre's notion of freedom as the ability to choose one's own being is too idealistic and does not take into account the real-world limitations and pressures that individuals face (Foucault, 1984).

Conclusion

Sartre's conception of choice and responsibility is a central aspect of his existentialist philosophy. His views on the absurdity of existence, the burden of freedom, and the importance of authenticity have significantly influenced modern thought. However, his views are not without criticism, and it is important to acknowledge the limitations of his perspective. Despite these criticisms, Sartre's ideas continue to be relevant and influential in the fields of ethics, philosophy, and psychology.

References

Foucault, M. (1984). The Use of Pleasure. New York: Pantheon Books.
Marcuse, H. (1964). One-Dimensional Man. Boston: Beacon Press.
Sartre, J.-P. (1943). L'Être et le Néant. Paris: Gallimard.
Sartre, J.-P. (1946). "Existentialism is a Humanism." In Existentialism from Dostoevsky to Camus. New York: Yale University Press.